Gothic Style Cat Tree vs Nightfall Cat Tree: Which Is Best for Your Cat’s Needs?
At Fur Child Wonderland, we love Happy & Polly; a brand with a funky vibe and unique aesthetic styles of a multitude of cat products.
Cat trees are more than just furniture; they’re places for climbing, scratching, lounging, and hiding. If you’re looking at Happy & Polly’s Gothic-style offerings, two popular picks are the Gothic Style Cat Tree and the Nightfall Cat Tree.
Both share style elements, but each has strengths making it a better fit depending on cat behavior, space, décor, and budget. Let’s compare them so you can decide which one’s better suited for your situation.
Nightfall Cat Tree ($109.99 - discounted from $129.99*)
Pros:
- Strong stability with wide base → less wobble, safer for energetic cats.
- Angled ladder helps senior or less agile cats access perches.
- Many perches + hammock + hanging toy = good enrichment.
- More affordable (especially on discount) for the features.
Cons:
- Less “branding” or dramatic theme compared to full gothic style. If the aesthetic is your priority, may feel less bold.
- Upper platforms are open; cats that prefer enclosed hideouts may want something more enclosed.
- Size may still be large for small apartments.
Gothic Style Cat Tree (*$99.99 up to $169.99 depending on size/color options)
Pros:
- Strong visual impact. Perfect for owners who care about décor and want a statement piece.
- Enclosed “coffin” beds provide privacy & cozy resting spots.
- Sisal posts + tall height let cats climb, scratch, perch.
- Multiple color options, which helps match your room décor.
Cons:
- The more decorative features may add weight / cost.
- Open design and elevated beds require stability; in wobbly or narrow spaces may be less safe.
- Might be less forgiving for older or less mobile cats if many vertical jumps required.
How to Choose: What’s Best Given Your Needs
Here are questions to ask yourself, and which model is likely better given your answers:
| Question | If Yes → Choose Nightfall | If Yes → Choose Gothic Style |
|---|---|---|
| Do your cats enjoy climbing and open perches rather than hiding? | ✅ Nightfall (more perches, ladder) | |
| Is home décor important, and do you want a dramatic centerpiece? | ✅ Gothic Style | |
| Is space limited / do you need a stable, wide base? | ✅ Nightfall | Possibly still Gothic, but check the space and stability |
| Do you have older cats, or cats with limited mobility? | ✅ Nightfall (ladder, gentler climbs) | Maybe, but the height/jumps might be harder unless many lower platforms |
| Do your cats like hiding / enclosed resting perch / more privacy? | ✅ Gothic Style | |
| Is budget a concern? | Nightfall tends to be more value for perches + features. | Gothic Style is more expensive, especially in premium finishes. |
Verdict & Recommendation
If you’re after a balance between style, function, and cost, the Nightfall Cat Tree is likely the smarter pick: stable, comfortable, well-featured, and less overwhelming in space requirement.
On the other hand, if your priority is decor & statement, and you want your cat furniture to stand out visually (without compromising on comfort), the Gothic Style Cat Tree is ideal. Just be mindful of dimensions and placement to ensure safety and stability, especially if your cats are active or you have more than one.
Where to Purchase:
If you want to check the current pricing, colors, and stock check out Happy & Polly's Cat trees here.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we believe are genuinely useful. *Prices listed here may change and are accurate at the time of publishing this page.